The closer a person is to our heart, the easier they can hurt it. Who cares about what some distant stranger thinks of us? Our family, however…

A man recently turned to the internet , claiming his own brother had always tormented him. The cruel behavior started in childhood and persisted all the way to early adulthood, when he finally decided that enough was enough and cut ties not just with his toxic sibling but also with their parents who enabled him.

Things were seemingly going great, but one day, the man received a call that would force him to confront the past.

Some siblings have rivalries, but these brothers had a particularly toxic relationship

Two men facing each other closely outdoors, illustrating family conflict and kidney donation tension.

Two men facing each other closely outdoors, illustrating family conflict and kidney donation tension. - 1

And supposedly, only one of them was responsible for all the bad blood between them

Text excerpt describing a man’s troubled relationship with his twin brother asking for a kidney donation after family conflict.

Text excerpt describing a man’s troubled relationship with his twin brother asking for a kidney donation after family conflict. - 2

Alt text: Man shares story of betrayal by family and the audacity of a kidney request after betrayal and loss of his brother.

Alt text: Man shares story of betrayal by family and the audacity of a kidney request after betrayal and loss of his brother. - 3

Text of a personal story about family drama involving betrayal, broken trust, and being treated unfairly by parents.

Text of a personal story about family drama involving betrayal, broken trust, and being treated unfairly by parents. - 4

Family asking man for kidney after what they did, leading to him letting his brother die, emotional family conflict story.

Family asking man for kidney after what they did, leading to him letting his brother die, emotional family conflict story. - 5

The final straw came when his brother mocked his sexuality, and his parents turned on him too

Two men smiling and eating popcorn in a theater, highlighting family audacity and kidney donation conflict themes.

Two men smiling and eating popcorn in a theater, highlighting family audacity and kidney donation conflict themes. - 6

Alt text: Emotional family conflict over organ donation after betrayal, highlighting kidney request and letting brother die.

Alt text: Emotional family conflict over organ donation after betrayal, highlighting kidney request and letting brother die. - 7

Text excerpt describing a man’s experience with family hardship and finding familial love and support elsewhere.

Text excerpt describing a man's experience with family hardship and finding familial love and support elsewhere. - 8

Text excerpt about family conflict and kidney donation after brother’s hospitalization involving tough decisions and betrayal.

Text excerpt about family conflict and kidney donation after brother’s hospitalization involving tough decisions and betrayal. - 9

Text excerpt describing painful memories and a hospital meeting about a family kidney request involving a twin brother.

Text excerpt describing painful memories and a hospital meeting about a family kidney request involving a twin brother. - 10

Text excerpt describing a family conflict involving a brother suffering from kidney failure and strained relationships.

Text excerpt describing a family conflict involving a brother suffering from kidney failure and strained relationships. - 11

After years of estrangement, however, the brother reached out, requesting a kidney

Man with nasal cannula lying in hospital bed, reflecting on family kidney request and difficult brother sacrifice.

Man with nasal cannula lying in hospital bed, reflecting on family kidney request and difficult brother sacrifice. - 12

Text excerpt about a man refusing to donate his kidney to a family member despite regrets and past conflicts.

Text excerpt about a man refusing to donate his kidney to a family member despite regrets and past conflicts. - 13

Text excerpt about family conflict over kidney donation and refusal to save brother despite their past treatment.

Text excerpt about family conflict over kidney donation and refusal to save brother despite their past treatment. - 14

Text excerpt showing a man reflecting on family duty, betrayal, and karma after his brother’s harmful actions.

Text excerpt showing a man reflecting on family duty, betrayal, and karma after his brother’s harmful actions. - 15

Text excerpt showing a man describing walking out after family conflict, related to kidney donation and loss of his brother.

Text excerpt showing a man describing walking out after family conflict, related to kidney donation and loss of his brother. - 16

Text excerpt about a family asking a man for a kidney after he lets his brother die, showing emotional conflict.

Text excerpt about a family asking a man for a kidney after he lets his brother die, showing emotional conflict. - 17

Text excerpt about family dynamics and kidney donation conflict after past mistreatment.

Text excerpt about family dynamics and kidney donation conflict after past mistreatment. - 18

Text excerpt discussing family conflict and kidney donation dilemma after brother’s death and strained relationships.

Text excerpt discussing family conflict and kidney donation dilemma after brother's death and strained relationships. - 19

Sometimes it’s not entirely clear who estranged who

In recent years, familial estrangement has become a hot topic. “Sibling estrangement can be really painful, and it’s also very stigmatized,” says Rin Reczek, a professor of sociology at Ohio State University, adding that people on both sides of an estrangement often feel a sense of failure, as though the split is somehow an indictment of them or their values.

According to her, there isn’t much data on how widespread sibling alienation is, but one German study suggests that almost 30 percent of siblings have experienced at least one period of estrangement.

A YouGov survey released last year found a similar figure and reported that nearly one-quarter of American adults say they are currently estranged from a sibling.

Dr. Reczek acknowledges that there are many reasons siblings become estranged. But research suggests that parental favoritism, whether real or imagined, can definitely drive a wedge between them, as can parental manipulation.

And while sibling estrangement can seem like the best path for some, psychologist Joshua Coleman, author of the book Rules of Estrangement , still describes it as a “cataclysmic event” for the family. Nieces, nephews, and cousins may lose touch, and parents may be pulled into taking sides, says Dr. Coleman, who has dealt with estrangement in his own family.

So quickly after posting his story, the man answered some of people’s biggest questions

Young man leaning against a wall looking distressed, reflecting on family kidney request after betrayal and loss.

Young man leaning against a wall looking distressed, reflecting on family kidney request after betrayal and loss. - 20 Text on screen highlighting a user editing a statement to clarify comments after a family kidney request controversy. - 21

Text about renal failure caused by a hardcore lifestyle of d***s and alcohol in a plain black font on white background.

Text about renal failure caused by a hardcore lifestyle of d***s and alcohol in a plain black font on white background. - 22

Text showing a person explaining their family tested to see if they were kidney matches but none were compatible.

Text showing a person explaining their family tested to see if they were kidney matches but none were compatible. - 23

Text excerpt explaining disowning family and changing last name, related to family kidney request and betrayal.

Text excerpt explaining disowning family and changing last name, related to family kidney request and betrayal. - 24

Text showing a family contacting a man about kidney donation despite past conflicts, highlighting difficult family dynamics.

Text showing a family contacting a man about kidney donation despite past conflicts, highlighting difficult family dynamics. - 25

Text excerpt discussing feelings about a brother and family dynamics related to kidney donation and trust.

Text excerpt discussing feelings about a brother and family dynamics related to kidney donation and trust. - 26

Text excerpt sharing a man’s reflections on family, loss, and choosing to let his brother die after a kidney request.

Text excerpt sharing a man’s reflections on family, loss, and choosing to let his brother die after a kidney request. - 27

Alt text: Man refuses to donate kidney to brother after family’s betrayal and mistreatment throughout his life.

Alt text: Man refuses to donate kidney to brother after family’s betrayal and mistreatment throughout his life. - 28

Even though some people supported the man for his decision

User comment discussing the risks of kidney surgery and family dynamics after a man refuses to donate a kidney.

User comment discussing the risks of kidney surgery and family dynamics after a man refuses to donate a kidney. - 29

Comment discussing kidney problems, family betrayal, and choosing self-care over toxic relatives in a difficult situation.

Comment discussing kidney problems, family betrayal, and choosing self-care over toxic relatives in a difficult situation. - 30

Reddit comment discussing family audacity to ask for a kidney after mistreatment and the man letting his brother die.

Reddit comment discussing family audacity to ask for a kidney after mistreatment and the man letting his brother die. - 31

Comment discussing family audacity and kidney request after betrayal, supporting man’s decision to let brother die.

Comment discussing family audacity and kidney request after betrayal, supporting man's decision to let brother die. - 32

Comment text on a forum about a kidney donation dilemma involving family conflict and personal boundaries.

Comment text on a forum about a kidney donation dilemma involving family conflict and personal boundaries. - 33

Comment discussing family asking for a kidney and the impact on health, kindness, and brother’s death.

Comment discussing family asking for a kidney and the impact on health, kindness, and brother’s death. - 34

Comment expressing support for man asked for a kidney by family after past mistreatment, letting brother die.

Comment expressing support for man asked for a kidney by family after past mistreatment, letting brother die. - 35

Reddit comment discussing obligation to donate a kidney to family after past mistreatment and letting brother die.

Reddit comment discussing obligation to donate a kidney to family after past mistreatment and letting brother die. - 36

Screenshot of a Reddit comment stating nobody is entitled to other people’s organs in a discussion about a kidney request.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment stating nobody is entitled to other people’s organs in a discussion about a kidney request. - 37

User comment expressing anger over family demanding a kidney after mistreatment, emphasizing kidney donation is a personal choice.

User comment expressing anger over family demanding a kidney after mistreatment, emphasizing kidney donation is a personal choice. - 38

Comment discussing family betrayal and kidney donation requests after years of neglect and selfish treatment by relatives.

Comment discussing family betrayal and kidney donation requests after years of neglect and selfish treatment by relatives. - 39

Comment on family audacity asking man for kidney after mistreatment, with advice on cutting contact for mental health.

Comment on family audacity asking man for kidney after mistreatment, with advice on cutting contact for mental health. - 40

Commenter shares experience with kidney donation and lack of family support during the process and decisions involved.

Commenter shares experience with kidney donation and lack of family support during the process and decisions involved. - 41

Comment expressing support for saying no to a family kidney request after mistreatment and advice on handling grieving and parents.

Comment expressing support for saying no to a family kidney request after mistreatment and advice on handling grieving and parents. - 42

Comment discussing family dynamics and emotional challenges involving kidney donation and a brother’s illness.

Comment discussing family dynamics and emotional challenges involving kidney donation and a brother's illness. - 43

Comment text about family betrayal and standing up for oneself after a kidney request controversy.

Comment text about family betrayal and standing up for oneself after a kidney request controversy. - 44

Comment expressing refusal to donate kidney to family after past betrayal, highlighting personal life and boundaries.

Comment expressing refusal to donate kidney to family after past betrayal, highlighting personal life and boundaries. - 45

Comment about family audacity asking man for kidney after their mistreatment, and his decision to let brother die.

Comment about family audacity asking man for kidney after their mistreatment, and his decision to let brother die. - 46

Comment about family asking for a kidney after mistreatment, kidney donation, and difficult family relationships.

Comment about family asking for a kidney after mistreatment, kidney donation, and difficult family relationships. - 47

Comment discussing family favoritism and a***e, and the impact on decisions about kidney donation and loyalty.

Comment discussing family favoritism and a***e, and the impact on decisions about kidney donation and loyalty. - 48

Comment expressing refusal to donate a kidney despite family pressure after past mistreatment and lack of support.

Comment expressing refusal to donate a kidney despite family pressure after past mistreatment and lack of support. - 49

Comment on a forum discussing a man refusing a kidney donation to family after past mistreatment, highlighting boundaries and choices.

Comment on a forum discussing a man refusing a kidney donation to family after past mistreatment, highlighting boundaries and choices. - 50

Reddit comment discussing refusal to donate kidney to family after past mistreatment, emphasizing personal choice and consequences.

Reddit comment discussing refusal to donate kidney to family after past mistreatment, emphasizing personal choice and consequences. - 51

Comment discussing family audacity asking for a kidney despite past harm, supporting decision not to help brother.

Comment discussing family audacity asking for a kidney despite past harm, supporting decision not to help brother. - 52

There were quite a few critics as well

Comment discussing family conflict and complex feelings around kidney donation between brothers after past mistreatment.

Comment discussing family conflict and complex feelings around kidney donation between brothers after past mistreatment. - 53

Comment expressing shock at family’s audacity to ask for a kidney after betrayal, highlighting pain and heartbreak over the situation.

Comment expressing shock at family’s audacity to ask for a kidney after betrayal, highlighting pain and heartbreak over the situation. - 54

Screenshot of a Reddit comment expressing strong emotions about a family asking for a kidney after mistreatment.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment expressing strong emotions about a family asking for a kidney after mistreatment. - 55

He then made another update, accusing his family even more

Text excerpt describing family conflict and kidney request, highlighting betrayal and emotional struggle in a personal story.

Text excerpt describing family conflict and kidney request, highlighting betrayal and emotional struggle in a personal story. - 56

Text excerpt showing resentment over family’s preferential treatment toward brother’s sports events, related to kidney donation conflict.

Text excerpt showing resentment over family’s preferential treatment toward brother’s sports events, related to kidney donation conflict. - 57

Family conflict over kidney donation after betrayal, leading to brother’s death and broken relationships.

Family conflict over kidney donation after betrayal, leading to brother's death and broken relationships. - 58

Text excerpt describing being kicked out by family for being bisexual, highlighting family audacity and betrayal.

Text excerpt describing being kicked out by family for being bisexual, highlighting family audacity and betrayal. - 59

Text excerpt about family favoring brother with kindness and money despite unfair treatment involving kidney request.

Text excerpt about family favoring brother with kindness and money despite unfair treatment involving kidney request. - 60

Text excerpt from a story about family conflict, kidney request, and estrangement after being kicked out at age 14.

Text excerpt from a story about family conflict, kidney request, and estrangement after being kicked out at age 14. - 61

Text post about family audacity asking for a kidney after past actions and letting brother die in a painful scenario.

Text post about family audacity asking for a kidney after past actions and letting brother die in a painful scenario. - 62

Text image showing a personal message about family conflict and asking for a restraining order due to lifelong hatred.

Text image showing a personal message about family conflict and asking for a restraining order due to lifelong hatred. - 63

By then, everyone was just done

Screenshot of a Reddit conversation discussing restraining orders and mentioning British nationality in text format.

Screenshot of a Reddit conversation discussing restraining orders and mentioning British nationality in text format. - 64

Commenter reflecting on family conflict and kidney donation, expressing sympathy and legal advice about restraining orders.

Commenter reflecting on family conflict and kidney donation, expressing sympathy and legal advice about restraining orders. - 65

Screenshot of a social media comment expressing shock about a family asking a man for a kidney after mistreatment.

Screenshot of a social media comment expressing shock about a family asking a man for a kidney after mistreatment. - 66

Comment text on a white background discussing family audacity related to asking for a kidney despite their past actions.

Comment text on a white background discussing family audacity related to asking for a kidney despite their past actions. - 67

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing family conflict involving a restraining order and accusations against a brother and parent.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing family conflict involving a restraining order and accusations against a brother and parent. - 68

Screenshot of a forum comment asking what a friend’s mother said after being told to kick someone out.

Screenshot of a forum comment asking what a friend’s mother said after being told to kick someone out. - 69

Comment expressing sympathy for family struggles and mentioning supportive parents and future adoptive parents.

Comment expressing sympathy for family struggles and mentioning supportive parents and future adoptive parents. - 70

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing family betrayal and the audacity to ask for a kidney after mistreatment.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing family betrayal and the audacity to ask for a kidney after mistreatment. - 71

Family asks man for kidney despite toxic history, leading to tragic consequences for his brother’s life.

Family asks man for kidney despite toxic history, leading to tragic consequences for his brother’s life. - 72

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a family asking a man for a kidney after mistreatment.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a family asking a man for a kidney after mistreatment. - 73

Comment suggesting to seek help online for a restraining order after family conflict involving a kidney request.

Comment suggesting to seek help online for a restraining order after family conflict involving a kidney request. - 74

Screenshot of a social media comment expressing anger toward a family asking for a kidney after mistreatment.

Screenshot of a social media comment expressing anger toward a family asking for a kidney after mistreatment. - 75

Screenshot of an online comment expressing sympathy about family issues related to kidney donation and betrayal.

Screenshot of an online comment expressing sympathy about family issues related to kidney donation and betrayal. - 76

Screenshot of an angry comment expressing strong refusal about family asking for a kidney after past mistreatment.

Screenshot of an angry comment expressing strong refusal about family asking for a kidney after past mistreatment. - 77

Reddit comment discussing family drama and betrayal related to kidney donation and brother’s death situation.

Reddit comment discussing family drama and betrayal related to kidney donation and brother’s death situation. - 78

Comment discussing family asking for a kidney despite past betrayals, suggesting cutting off contact completely.

Comment discussing family asking for a kidney despite past betrayals, suggesting cutting off contact completely. - 79

Thanks! Check out the results:

Subscribe to Access <br/> Exclusive Polls - 80

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Unlock an Enhanced Experience with Bored Panda Premium

Go ad-free, access unlimited content, and enjoy our sleek dark mode. Your favorite stories, uninterrupted.

Man Refuses To Donate His Kidney To Save Twin Brother, Family Spams Him With Calls After His Death - 81

No fees, cancel anytime

Taylor Swift Offers Rare Behind-The-Scenes Peek At Her Opalite Video Shoot - 82 Olympian Makes Stunning Admission After Judge's Conspicuous Scores Ignite Cheating Accusations - 83

Olympian Makes Stunning Admission After Judge’s Conspicuous Scores Ignite Cheating Accusations

New Mom Is Stunned That MIL Called CPS On Her Just Because She Had Dumped Her Son, Goes No-Contact - 84

New Mom Is Stunned That MIL Called CPS On Her Just Because She Had Dumped Her Son, Goes No-Contact